Skip to main content

Tiny Rant on Chapter 10

Don't want to be that guy, but there is a small part in chapter 10 that irks me. 

First of all, what the hell can you conclude from that one question to test his IQ? A newborn baby could have gotten that right by chance. 

Second of all, Zheng Xuan/the author is massively confusing intellectual disability(ID) with autism. In the context of the story, it could just be the character that is not knowledgeable. ID and autism are two different disorders that have a high comorbidity rate, so while they commonly occur together, they are not the same. While Huang Ji does show symptoms of autism, he was only diagnosed with a mild ID, which is what Zheng Xuan is basing his statements on. In addition, while a lot of savants are autistic, Savant Syndrome is still a very rare occurrence among them. Though I do understand this is a common misconception. It's not that you have to have autism to have Savant Syndrome, but Zheng Xuan is clearly confusing autism and ID given his statement about how people with "ID" tend to demonstrate superior abilities in certain areas.

The End.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Omniscient - Chapter 12: Internet Data

Just wanted to address a review I saw. While there are elements of Chinese nationalism (duh), it's pretty good compared to other urban Chinese novels. Doesn't mean it's good, but for me it's tolerable. It just stands out because, a) it's China, and b) we're unused to it. Many works of fiction tend to highlight or emphasize their country of origin. This novel is no different. Like if the novel said USA is the center of the universe, you probably wouldn't bat an eye. But China... Of course, I can understand if anyone feel's uncomfortable about it.

The Omniscient - Chapter 2: A Surprisingly Blunt Letter

"Huh? Who saw what?" Wang Meng was confused.           Huang Ji didn't give him a straightforward answer. Pausing for a moment, he pointed at the old tree by the road saying, "This morning when I was walking this way I saw Li Fan from far away playing behind that tree. If Dr. Liang went out, he should have seen."           Wang Meng asked in astonishment, "Why didn't you mention such an important piece of information earlier?"           Huang Ji answered blankly, "Sorry, I've got a slow reaction. I just thought of it.."           "Uh…" Wang Meng was speechless, this was after all a kid with an intellectual disability.           Right when he was about to go question Li Fan, the village chief had also walked out earlier and overheard Huang Ji's words. Puzzled, he asked, "You're talking about Lil' Li's son?"         ...